Appreciating Art
As
I walked through the Sacagawea Art Collection, this colorful piece by
Mai Wyn Schantz- Oil on Aluminum, stood out to me the most. I
connected particularly with Mai's artwork because I work early enough
to be able to see the sun rise, something I never take for granted.
So now that I think about it, sunrises are one of my favorite things
(along with the sun setting, of course).
I
immediately notice the focal point as the sun about to rise,
as if Mai wanted to give the viewer a sense of anticipation for the
day to begin. The contrast to this is the remains of the night, light
to dark blues and purples, floating slowly up the aluminum sheet. It
is then that I see the color ending by a horizontal border of
aluminum – showing the grayscale that's underneath the oil. I can
now note the space the piece lies in, and the lines that are present.
The text explains, “Lines may be straight, angular or curvy. They
may be thick or thin, continuous or interrupted. The edges of a page
or screen represent lines” (p.46). Despite the line where the water
meets the sky, most lines in this painting make out the shapes of the
clouds, and the reflection and ripple of the water.
Why
do you think Mai decided to use her medium (aluminum) as a horizontal
border? Do you think this intentional border helps gain texture and
negative space or limits the colorful focal point with dull tones?
Next,
I recognize the horizontal line perspective, where the sky meets the
water. This gives me a feeling of distance with the horizon. The
yellow in the center also creates an atmospheric perspective that
allows the blue tones to circulate the image and move the eye into the center of warmer
colors. Also note the fading into lighter blue on the water from the
reflection of the sun's rays. The layout appears visually unbalanced
to me, and going back to the atmospheric perspective, Chapter 5 of
the text mentions, “
Colors in the foreground have darker richer values than colors in the
distance, which tend to fade and wash out” (p.54). In this case,
the rising sun is creating a fade within the water that reflects the
lighter areas of the sky.
I
found this piece to be aesthetically pleasing, and was able to
connect it further with a photo I took last year:
I
couldn't help but relate Mai's paintings to the warm colors presented
in my photograph, with their being a horizontal line perspective with
the water and sky. I also found an appreciation for cool and warm
saturated colors, which adds asymmetrical balance.
It's
said that “good design controls the eye's flow through composition”
(p.53). I think that has been greatly achieved here!

The sun setting is a calming force and the sun rising is an exhilarating force. Depending on whether you are a pessimist or an optimist this picture can evoke many different feelings! Lulu G
ReplyDeleteThis was another favorite of mine from the collection! I personally love photos/portraits of the sky and sun and this is stunning! I think I'm drawn to the lines too. Looking at this art work, I can see and feel hopeful as each day begins.
ReplyDelete-Melinda
Christy -Beautiful! I liked how you related your sun setting picture with Mai's painting and analyzed the elements you saw in both.
ReplyDeleteNycolle Bradford
ReplyDeleteI love this picture because Il of pictures of Sunsets and this was a close second for me!
Jen P. As with the others, this was one that drew me as well. I love the contrasting color of the dark blue sky with the vibrant reds and yellows.
ReplyDeleteYou asked why she might have used aluminum for the borders. First of all, I hadn't noticed that! So I looked at the pic for a while and tried to put a different border on it in my mind. Not much worked. First of all, I love that the border was only the top and bottom - it didn't constrain the image. And the aluminum? The more I thought about it, the more I thought white would have been too stark, and the steely color complemented the blue better. It's also a reflective surface - as is the water in the painting. Just my thoughts!
Katelyn, what a beautiful photo! The similarities between these two pieces are fantastic! I particularly like the way both have a horizontal line at the horizon, with more organic and free-flowing lines in the sky. I like the way this composition forces me to look at the center point, and then bounce back and forth between the upper and lower regions before settling on the center point again.
ReplyDeleteJenna
Stephanie W.
ReplyDeleteKatelyn, this painting was a close second for me! When I first saw it I was very "meh" but then when I realized it was painted on aluminum, it gave it a whole different feel.
I love the juxtaposition of the fluidity of the water and colorful sunrise against the hard, cold, inorganic form of the aluminum. The aluminum brings out the warmth of the sunlight in a way that wouldn't have been as successful if the borders were just painted in that tone of grey.
Michelle-
ReplyDeleteThere is a fractal pattern to the clouds and the body of water which is very prevalent in nature. This helps to unify the piece. The light yellow value of the rising sun is the light source and focal point of the painting with gradients of darker colors surrounding it. the darkest being at the edges. I especially like the red tones in the water below and the light blue clear sky above the focal point. Perhaps the dark and reflective aluminum was chosen to give the audience a sense of continuation of the water and sky which would be less present with a light background or border. This would follow the principle of continuity in Gestalt Theory, "Our mind will continue a pattern beyond its ending points." p 60
Chris A-
ReplyDeleteI love the contrast of the colors in this painting. I also love sunrises and sunsets. I love that you have a photo you took to go with this painting.
Jenny Pollen The Representative
ReplyDeleteThe colors are great in this painting. In the book when they talked about art having Value, I could see the value in this. The color tones in the top painting puts a lot of emphasize on the sun. Nice pick!
Jenny Pollen The Representative
ReplyDeleteThe colors are great in this painting. In the book when they talked about art having Value, I could see the value in this. The color tones in the top painting puts a lot of emphasize on the sun. Nice pick!
Jenny Pollen The Representative
ReplyDeleteThe colors are great in this painting. In the book when they talked about art having Value, I could see the value in this. The color tones in the top painting puts a lot of emphasize on the sun. Nice pick!
Kelly Lawler ~ Visually, this painting sucks you right in! The contrasts of color is amazing! Gorgeous ombre effect of the sun setting caught by the artist. Just beautiful
ReplyDeleteThat picture your took is stunning. You're right - the painting is very similar. The biggest difference I'm seeing in the colors is that in the painting, the oranges, yellows and red colors of the sun are sandwiched between the blues of the sky and water. In the photo you took, the yellow of the sun is being reflected upon the water, giving it a much brighter tone.
ReplyDeleteLeah Stikel
Heather - Katelyn, while reading your blog, I can't help notice how articulate you are in this topic of art. Is that just how you write / speak or are you really that well versed in art ( or am I that ignorant )?
ReplyDeleteWhile I am able to appreciate the beauty of the sunset and the brilliance of all the colors, I would have never thought to ask myself (Or anyone else) about the purpose and intention of using the aluminum as a border. Very interesting.
Katelyn - Thanks everyone, I'm glad you enjoyed my post! And Heather, I think when I communicate through writing it sounds much better than my speaking skills! I'm able to go back and erase something that may not make sense, but I'm glad you saw that I understood what to look for in this piece! I'll give most of the credit to the book, since I was only familiar with some of this vocab :)
ReplyDelete